During a panel at Web Summit in Lisbon, SAG-AFTRA CEO Duncan Crabtree-Ireland said that when actors and performers find their images or voices misused by AI, the overwhelming majority want the material removed rather than seeking financial compensation.
Crabtree-Ireland told the audience that more than nine times out of ten, members’ primary concern is stopping the misuse. He emphasized that most people aren’t looking to sue for profit — they simply object to having their likeness exploited and want it to end.
Speaking in a Deadline-moderated discussion called “Hollywood’s Identity Crisis,” Crabtree-Ireland recounted that his own image had been used without consent while SAG-AFTRA members were striking in 2023. He used the anecdote to frame support for the proposed No Fakes Act, legislation designed to give individuals stronger control over how their voice and likeness are used.
He argued that people should be able to decide what words appear to come from them and how they are portrayed online. A law like the No Fakes Act, he said, would create a mechanism for that control — and, he added, it’s not about lining anyone’s pockets. The intent, according to Crabtree-Ireland, is to pressure platforms to remove content that uses someone’s image, voice or likeness without permission.
Crabtree-Ireland shared the panel with Dan Neely, co-founder and CEO of Vermillio, a platform that helps music, publishing and entertainment clients — including high-profile individuals — license and protect their likenesses.
AI dominated conversation at Web Summit, and Crabtree-Ireland was asked whether his union members’ views on the technology are shifting. He said there’s growing recognition that, with sensible rules, AI and performers can coexist. There’s an acceptance among many that AI cannot realistically be stopped outright.
He also acknowledged a segment of the membership that remains firmly opposed to AI. Crabtree-Ireland said he hears from those members regularly; they want a ban and are frustrated that the union hasn’t been able to impose one. He estimated that this group represents roughly 10–15% of the membership.
At the same time, some actors are interested in using AI as a creative aid. Crabtree-Ireland noted that certain members want AI tools to augment their craft, though none want to be replaced — the creative act itself is central to why they work. The ideal, he suggested, is access to assistive tools that broaden artistic possibilities without eliminating human creators.
He even quipped that if the industry could find that balance, AI resources could be redirected toward other societal benefits, like medical research.
Speaking from Web Summit’s main stage — a venue that earlier featured the AI-generated performer Tilly Norwood — Crabtree-Ireland stressed the importance of distinguishing between wholly synthetic creations and AI-generated replicas of actual people.
He warned against treating algorithmic outputs as if they were human. A character produced by generative AI is not a person; it doesn’t possess a life or lived experience. One of the major challenges, he said, is the tendency to anthropomorphize AI systems and to blur the line between genuine human beings and artificial entities.

Daniel Hayes is a business journalist with a focus on market trends, startups, and corporate strategies.
His sharp analysis and investigative reports make complex financial topics accessible to all readers.



